Rapporter • Board Game Arena

Alle rapporter

Carcassonne rapporterer

#33628: "Tournament Final with a tie. Where is the rule that declares the winner?"

fixed: Bug er blevet fixet

Hvad handler denne rapport om?

Carcassonne #146018119

Hvad skete der? Vær venlig og vælg nedenunder

Regler: En regel i dette spil er ikke blevet overholdt

Hvad skete der? Vær venlig og vælg nedenunder

Regler: En regel i dette spil er ikke blevet overholdt

Vær sød at undersøge, om der allerede er sendt en besked om emnet

Hvis ja, venligst STEM for denne rapport. Rapporter med flest stemmer er dem der får PRIORITET!

#	Status	Votes	Game	Type	Title	Last update

Detaljeret beskrivelse

Rapporthistorik

7. Feb 2021 22:39 • Waddington • Fejlen er ikke blevet reproduceret af udviklere endnu:

This creates a lot of confusion in big tournaments, needs a clarification. Or even an implementation os a manual tiebreaker: The tournament orginizer could set the criteria for tiebreaker.

8. Feb 2021 05:38 • SmilingDevil • Fejlen er ikke blevet reproduceret af udviklere endnu:

Maybe the meeple left unused could be used here? If you manage to score the same amount of points tying down less work force this would be showing to be more effective as a leader?

8. Feb 2021 17:04 • Waddington • Fejlen er ikke blevet reproduceret af udviklere endnu:

No, meeples are commonly used in total in the game. There's chance the tie persists.

In international competitions, in case a match ands in a tie, the winner is the player who didn't start the match.

The logic behind it is that the first player gets to play one extra tile in the total of 71 us the starting tiles in the base name.

This criteria is well accepted in the community.

9. Jun 2024 19:05 • houdini_fr • Fejlen er ikke blevet reproduceret af udviklere endnu:

this improvement would be nice.

10. Jul 2024 17:33 • Baronius83 • Fejlen er ikke blevet reproduceret af udviklere endnu:

Hello, I had the same issue just today. I had a draw with a player with an upper Elo in a single elimination tournament, he played first...and after a 90-90 draw, I was eliminated. It's quite frustrating, especially when you force a much stronger player to a tie, and BGA does not apply an internationally accepted rule (in case og a tie, second player wins)

Here is the link to the game, thank you in advance

boardgamearena.com/table?table=535368672

17. Jul 2024 15:19 • thoun • Bug er blevet fixet:

The suggested tiebreaker have been implemented ("Last in order of play")

17. Jul 2024 15:34 • Waddington • Bug er blevet fixet:

Nice, thank you Thoun, this is a great and really important improvement in BGA rules that will strengthen tournaments and competitive play!

Is this also valid for Arena matches?

17. Jul 2024 15:38 • thoun • Bug er blevet fixet:

Yes it will apply to all games started after this update

17. Jul 2024 18:42 • szigfrid • Bug er blevet fixet:

Even in ongoing Swiss system or round robin tournaments? (Where there might be players who got 0.5 point for their already finished tied games.)
In my opinion the change should only be used in single elimination tournaments.

17. Jul 2024 20:54 • Baronius83 • Bug er blevet fixet:

Thank you very much, good job

13. Aug 2024 10:35 • szigfrid • Bug er blevet fixet:

Here's an example of the unintended side effects of this change.
In this swiss system tournament there were tied games both before and after the tiebreaker modification therefore some of these games ended with a real tie (0.5 points for both players) and some of them were won by one of the players:
boardgamearena.com/tournament?id=307099

I think we should agree that these kinds of rule changes should not happen during the course of a tournament.

Please improve so that the tiebreaker can be specified in the tournament settings. In Swiss system or round robin tournaments the tie does not necessarily have to be resolved.

Tilføj noget til denne rapport

Vær sød at tilføje, det du finder relevant for at vi kan løse fejlen i spillet eller forstå dit forslag:

Et andet bord-ID / træk ID
Løste F5 problemet?
Skete problemet flere gange? Hver gang? Tilfældigt?
Hvis du har et skærmbillede af denne fejl (god øvelse), kan du bruge Imgur.com til at uploade den og kopiere/indsætte linket her.

Annullér Opdatér rapport

#33628: "Tournament Final with a tie. Where is the rule that declares the winner?"

Hvad handler denne rapport om?

Hvad skete der? Vær venlig og vælg nedenunder

Hvad skete der? Vær venlig og vælg nedenunder

Vær sød at undersøge, om der allerede er sendt en besked om emnet

Detaljeret beskrivelse

Rapporthistorik

Tilføj noget til denne rapport

skift rapport status til:

Hjælp

Bidrag

Navigér

Følg os