Alle rapporter
DVONN rapporterer
#98418: "Last move marker"
rejected: Udviklerne tænker ikke at det er en god ide eller at omkostningerne vil være for høje
1
Hvad handler denne rapport om?
Hvad skete der? Vær venlig og vælg nedenunder
Foreslag: efter min mening vil følgende forbedre spillets implementering betydeligt
Detaljeret beskrivelse
• Forklar venligst dit forslag præcist og sammenfattende, så det er så let som muligt at forstå, hvad du mener.
I know there are logs on the upper left. For mobiles users, it’s better to show last move in turn based games, like “a red circle around the move”. Players could read the table quickly. Thx.• Hvilken browser bruger du?
Mobile
Rapporthistorik
13. sep 2023 19:05 • ElNSTElN • Udviklerne ønsker flere informationer omkring forslaget:
I experimented with this feature during development but never was really with it. Typically I not only want to see my opponents last move but also mine. Since both players could have moved onto the same spot, that would be not so clear.
Also a move could have been made so that the moving piece lost contact to the DVONN pieces and got removed. Another potential iritation for some.
Finally when thinking about the other games of the GIPF series already, there are some where a player does multiple actions. From my point of view, a replay is just better.
BUT: I also play on mobile from time to time and had a hard time hitting that tiny replay button above the move table. I made the board (edge where no pieces are) clickable and trigger the replay button this way.
Does that help you?
Also a move could have been made so that the moving piece lost contact to the DVONN pieces and got removed. Another potential iritation for some.
Finally when thinking about the other games of the GIPF series already, there are some where a player does multiple actions. From my point of view, a replay is just better.
BUT: I also play on mobile from time to time and had a hard time hitting that tiny replay button above the move table. I made the board (edge where no pieces are) clickable and trigger the replay button this way.
Does that help you?
20. sep 2023 15:57 • covadis • Udviklerne ønsker flere informationer omkring forslaget:
May be just highlight the where the token was and where it is ?
20. sep 2023 23:07 • ElNSTElN • Udviklerne tænker ikke at det er en god ide eller at omkostningerne vil være for høje:
As I already mentioned above, you can move a piece in a way that it loses connection to the DVONN pieces and thus gets removed. The result would be 2 markers without any piece.
Some of the other GIPF games have more complicated moves - even multiple actions, e.g. YINSH:
- put marker into ring
- move ring
- turn some markers
- remove markers (when 5 in a row) - could include the marker just put before
- remove ring - could be the ring that just moved
So many highlights, so much confusion!
Just press replay, or do it step by step for better clarity if new the game!
Easy! :)
Some of the other GIPF games have more complicated moves - even multiple actions, e.g. YINSH:
- put marker into ring
- move ring
- turn some markers
- remove markers (when 5 in a row) - could include the marker just put before
- remove ring - could be the ring that just moved
So many highlights, so much confusion!
Just press replay, or do it step by step for better clarity if new the game!
Easy! :)
25. sep 2023 21:31 • TripleLSupreme • Udviklerne tænker ikke at det er en god ide eller at omkostningerne vil være for høje:
I know this was closed but I would still suggest looking at this again. Simple highlighting the spot your opponent started and moved to would be helpful. Turn based you have to constantly review the log which is even worse of a user experience on mobile.
25. sep 2023 21:38 • ElNSTElN • Udviklerne tænker ikke at det er en god ide eller at omkostningerne vil være for høje:
Did you try out what I wrote in my first reply here on September 13th?
You don't have to review the log. You just click on the replay button and see both your own and the opponents last move.
On mobile, you can also "click" anywhere on the outer rim of the board (where no pieces are) to trigger the same.
You don't have to review the log. You just click on the replay button and see both your own and the opponents last move.
On mobile, you can also "click" anywhere on the outer rim of the board (where no pieces are) to trigger the same.
Tilføj noget til denne rapport
Vær sød at tilføje, det du finder relevant for at vi kan løse fejlen i spillet eller forstå dit forslag:
- Et andet bord-ID / træk ID
- Løste F5 problemet?
- Skete problemet flere gange? Hver gang? Tilfældigt?
- Hvis du har et skærmbillede af denne fejl (god øvelse), kan du bruge Imgur.com til at uploade den og kopiere/indsætte linket her.
