Alle rapporter
Farkle rapporterer
#87625: "pause game when 1st roll scores all five dice"
rejected: Udviklerne tænker ikke at det er en god ide eller at omkostningerne vil være for høje
1
Hvad handler denne rapport om?
Hvad skete der? Vær venlig og vælg nedenunder
Foreslag: efter min mening vil følgende forbedre spillets implementering betydeligt
Detaljeret beskrivelse
• Forklar venligst dit forslag præcist og sammenfattende, så det er så let som muligt at forstå, hvad du mener.
In a turn based game my turn came up and I discovered that I scored all five dice and had already re-rolled. It would be a better gaming experience to have the game pause after the first die roll when all five dice will score.
Without doing so, it feels like the game is playing itself as no input is being asked for from the player. Obviously, a player should always score all five dice and re-roll, but the active player doesn't get to see this happening.• Hvilken browser bruger du?
Google Chrome v112
Rapporthistorik
30. apr 2023 18:09 • travbot • Dette forslag er endnu ikke analyseret af udviklerne:
Letting the active player see what happens for the entirety turn would be a good improvement.
30. apr 2023 19:20 • ufm • Udviklerne tænker ikke at det er en god ide eller at omkostningerne vil være for høje:
Check the game log
7. maj 2023 20:51 • bookman01 • Udviklerne tænker ikke at det er en god ide eller at omkostningerne vil være for høje:
Especially for a higher scoring roll, some may want to bank the first roll rather than risk a farkle on the second roll.
7. maj 2023 23:01 • ufm • Udviklerne tænker ikke at det er en god ide eller at omkostningerne vil være for høje:
Not needed as first rolls and hot dice rolls never farkle due to 'six no scoring dice' combination
27. maj 2023 4:35 • emilyfofemily • Udviklerne tænker ikke at det er en god ide eller at omkostningerne vil være for høje:
Right but with piggybacking, a player might want to strategically not re-roll so as to not give the other player a chance to piggyback. So there really should be the option to not roll when all dice score.
27. maj 2023 7:08 • ufm • Udviklerne tænker ikke at det er en god ide eller at omkostningerne vil være for høje:
I adopted this rule as I don't like escaping piggyback like that:
'Players may be required to make at least one additional throw when they have hot dice, even if they have accumulated a high enough score that they would choose not to risk farkling.'
After all, I added piggyback to give players more chances of comeback and add more tactical decisions.
'Players may be required to make at least one additional throw when they have hot dice, even if they have accumulated a high enough score that they would choose not to risk farkling.'
After all, I added piggyback to give players more chances of comeback and add more tactical decisions.
28. maj 2023 18:06 • Zach_Attakk • Udviklerne tænker ikke at det er en god ide eller at omkostningerne vil være for høje:
Having a game come up with a score already present and no indication what happened to cause it, is unintuitive and confusing. Playing on mobile doesn't show the game log unless it is expressly opened.
Simply rejecting the suggestion because "check the game log" is a dismissive and unprofessional response.
Simply rejecting the suggestion because "check the game log" is a dismissive and unprofessional response.
29. maj 2023 15:47 • ufm • Udviklerne tænker ikke at det er en god ide eller at omkostningerne vil være for høje:
You are playing turn-based games. Do you seriously expect every action between your last move and the current status to be played every time you connect?
Also, I received requests to automate actions and quicken turn-based games a lot more than you think. I'm not reverting this.
Also, I received requests to automate actions and quicken turn-based games a lot more than you think. I'm not reverting this.
2. jun 2023 5:31 • Lael • Udviklerne tænker ikke at det er en god ide eller at omkostningerne vil være for høje:
I do not understand why when the first player reaches the winning score the losing player is given an opportunity to roll until they farkle trying to win. I've been playing farkle for years and it's always been first person to the target score wins. This seems like an unfair advantage to the losing player who will just keep going until they farkle every time, whereas the winning player is debating and risking each time they roll. I would like the opportunity to turn that off and have the game end when the target score is reached.
2. jun 2023 6:14 • ufm • Udviklerne tænker ikke at det er en god ide eller at omkostningerne vil være for høje:
'I played by this rule for years' is not a valid argument as there are tons of house rules in public domain games. I cannot implement all suggested rules obviously.
The rule in question should be a major variant rule or should improve the game significantly, then whether to implement it or not can be considered.
I don't think your suggestion qualifies either of these.
The rule in question should be a major variant rule or should improve the game significantly, then whether to implement it or not can be considered.
I don't think your suggestion qualifies either of these.
3. jul 2024 0:12 • Lynnguist • Udviklerne tænker ikke at det er en god ide eller at omkostningerne vil være for høje:
It's very disturbing to load the game and have a score before I've even had a chance to enter the game area. Could you add a brief delay for the first turn to make sure all players are actually in the game area before game play starts? Yes, I can check the log but I'm missing out on the game play by not being able to see my first turn(s) if I happen to get all scoring dice.
Once or twice I've clicked "accept" to start a game and then when I'm on the board discovered I have 2000 points or something like that with the only record on the game log. It would be nice to actually play along with those first rolls rather than having them magically appear.
I'm not suggesting changing the autoscoring in general, just for delaying the scoring for the very first roll so everyone can see what happened.
Once or twice I've clicked "accept" to start a game and then when I'm on the board discovered I have 2000 points or something like that with the only record on the game log. It would be nice to actually play along with those first rolls rather than having them magically appear.
I'm not suggesting changing the autoscoring in general, just for delaying the scoring for the very first roll so everyone can see what happened.
Tilføj noget til denne rapport
Vær sød at tilføje, det du finder relevant for at vi kan løse fejlen i spillet eller forstå dit forslag:
- Et andet bord-ID / træk ID
- Løste F5 problemet?
- Skete problemet flere gange? Hver gang? Tilfældigt?
- Hvis du har et skærmbillede af denne fejl (god øvelse), kan du bruge Imgur.com til at uploade den og kopiere/indsætte linket her.
